Browse by intervention

Vitamin B12: what it changed, and what it did not

One intervention, every measured benefit and result that did not improve. See who it moved for, where it stayed neutral or went the other way, and the next hypothesis Phoenix can validate.

How to read this

Observational research: real APOE4 carriers tracked over time, each compared with their own earlier self. Members chose their interventions, with no randomisation or placebo group. Everything else they changed is shown beside each result.

Read the full methods and limits

Key findings

Phoenix has measured Vitamin B12 against 2 exact outcomes for APOE4 carriers. The support cohort has 76 B12-family users and 19 with a repeat homocysteine result; clean eligibility is not published. The support cohort has 76 B12-family users and 15 with a repeat vitamin B12 level; clean eligibility is not published.

Vitamin B12 evidence by outcome
OutcomeDirectionWhat we observed
HomocysteineRepeated positiveThe support cohort has 76 B12-family users and 19 with a repeat homocysteine result; clean eligibility is not published.
Vitamin B12 levelPositive individual resultThe support cohort has 76 B12-family users and 15 with a repeat vitamin B12 level; clean eligibility is not published.

Do I need B12 shots or very high B12, and does B12 protect my brain?

B12 raises B12 levels, and together with folate it lowers homocysteine. Extra B12 does not sharpen thinking in people who are not low, but B vitamins probably slowed brain shrinkage in people with memory problems whose homocysteine was high and omega-3 was good. Phoenix's carrier target is B12 of 500-900 pg/mL; ask your doctor whether a methylmalonic acid test is needed before considering injections.

What the research says

Grade B

APOE4-specific evidence: none

Extra B12 does not improve thinking in people who are not deficient, but B vitamins probably slowed brain shrinkage in people with memory problems who had high homocysteine and good omega-3, and B12 pills probably work about as well as shots.

Key studies

  • Markun 2021, NutrientsGrade A

    16 trials, 6,276 people without deficiency: B12 alone or with other B vitamins did not improve cognition or depression.

    Read on PubMed (opens in a new tab)
  • Smith 2010, PLoS OneGrade A

    VITACOG trial in MCI: B vitamins lowered homocysteine and slowed brain shrinkage, most in those with high homocysteine.

    Read on PubMed (opens in a new tab)
  • Jerneren 2015, American Journal of Clinical NutritionGrade B

    Same trial: the slowing of brain shrinkage (40%) appeared only in people with good omega-3 levels.

    Read on PubMed (opens in a new tab)
2 more key studies
  • Wang 2018, CochraneGrade A

    Three small trials: high-dose oral B12 raised levels about as well as injections; low-quality evidence.

    Read on PubMed (opens in a new tab)
  • Homocysteine Lowering Trialists' Collaboration 2005, American Journal of Clinical NutritionGrade A

    Meta-analysis of trials: folic acid lowers homocysteine, with B12 adding a further small reduction.

    Read on PubMed (opens in a new tab)

What Kevin and experts say

1 passage for, 2 with a caution

Now showing: Dr. Grant Fraser · 19:33

Open on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

For1 passage

  1. 19:33APOE4 Biomarkers Pt.1: Omega 3 and Homocysteine - Why Your "Normal" Labs Results Might Be Lying ·

    Food, especially fish, often beats B12 pills.

    “go to food rather than supplements.”

    Dr. Grant Fraser, Board-certified anti-aging and family medicine physician, APOE4 carrier

With a caution2 passages

  1. 17:00APOE4 Biomarkers Pt.1: Omega 3 and Homocysteine - Why Your "Normal" Labs Results Might Be Lying ·

    Injectable B12 only helps if methylmalonic acid is high.

    “If your MMA is normal, you're not going to get any benefit by pushing that.”

    Dr. Grant Fraser, Board-certified anti-aging and family medicine physician, APOE4 carrier

  2. 32:55Menopause & APOE4: When Doctors Disagree on HRT ·

    She says everyone should give their B12 level some thought.

    “everybody should have some consideration of their B12 levels”

    Dr. Ashanthi Gajaweera, Board-certified neurologist, Menopause Society certified practitioner (Healthspan Neurology)

Last reviewed

Questions about Vitamin B12

What is the effect of Vitamin B12 for APOE4 carriers?

Phoenix has measured Vitamin B12 against 2 exact outcomes for APOE4 carriers. The support cohort has 76 B12-family users and 19 with a repeat homocysteine result; clean eligibility is not published. The support cohort has 76 B12-family users and 15 with a repeat vitamin B12 level; clean eligibility is not published.

Does Vitamin B12 change Homocysteine for APOE4 carriers?

The support cohort has 76 B12-family users and 19 with a repeat homocysteine result; clean eligibility is not published. Support: 78 logged members, 21 members with repeats, 2 observations, 42 measurements.

Does Vitamin B12 change Vitamin B12 level for APOE4 carriers?

The support cohort has 76 B12-family users and 15 with a repeat vitamin B12 level; clean eligibility is not published. Support: 77 logged members, 16 members with repeats, 1 observations, 32 measurements.

What changed for real APOE4 carriers?

Search by health goal or intervention to see what changed for real members, including results that moved the wrong way.

Want to try vitamin B12 and see whether it works for you? Phoenix tracks it beside your labs and how you feel.

Apply to join Phoenix

Vitamin B12 · 2 outcomes shown.

Intervention categorySupplements
InterventionVitamin B12

Vitamin B12

SupplementsOutcomes: 2

Homocysteine: Status Not enough data

Vitamin B12 level: Status Not enough data

The Beat the Odds Study

The 43-page study: what members tried, how their bloodwork and wearable results changed, and what else changed alongside them.

Download the Beat the Odds Study

Turn evidence into your next test

I built this so nobody has to be the first to try something.

476 members have already tried, measured and logged. Join Phoenix and your next blood draw joins the same Navigator you are reading.

Apply to join Phoenix

Full research index

Find a goal, marker, intervention or question

Choose an outcome, like LDL cholesterol or sleep, or an intervention, like training: both paths open the same measured records.